Photon vs Blue Replies

Compare Photon and Blue Replies side by side: iMessage features, channels, developer tools, pricing and compliance, checked on each provider's own site.

Photon

Open-source agent framework with managed iMessage
Starting price
$25/month (Pro)
Free plan
Free: shared iMessage lines, up to 10 users (2.0 beta: 25 shared iMessage assignments and $100 credit)

Blue Replies

iMessage and FaceTime API with a free phone-bound sandbox
Starting price
Custom quote
Free plan
Sandbox: free, no expiry, your own phone plus up to 5 verified contacts

Photon supports 75 of the 77 features compared here, and Blue Replies supports 36.

Feature comparison

FeaturePhotonBlue Replies
iMessage messaging
iMessage
SupportedManaged cloud lines, or your own Mac with the local provider
Supported
Group chats
SupportedOn the Business plan (dedicated lines)
SupportedCreate, send to and receive from groups; changelog says up to 25 participants.
Group management
SupportedCreate groups and add, remove or leave members; Business plan (dedicated lines)
SupportedAdd and remove members, and leave (best effort).
Group name and photo
SupportedRename groups and set group photos; Business plan (dedicated lines)
SupportedRename and set the group photo; only the line that created the group.
Mentions
SupportedSend @mentions in multipart messages and read mention ranges on inbound
Not listed
Tapbacks
SupportedSix native tapbacks plus emoji reactions, send and receive
SupportedAdd or remove the six classic tapbacks; message.reaction webhook for inbound.
Threaded replies
Supported
SupportedreplyTo renders as a quoted-reply thread in Messages.
Typing indicators
Supported
SupportedSend typing; message.typing webhook when the recipient types.
Read receipts
SupportedMark chats read and receive read events; group receipts are best-effort
SupportedSend read receipts and receive message.read events.
Edit and unsend
SupportedEdit within 15 minutes and unsend within 2 minutes (Apple limits)
SupportedEdit up to 5 times within 15 minutes; unsend within 2 minutes.
Message effects
SupportedAll bubble and screen effects, including invisible ink
Supported12 bubble and screen effects.
Animated text effects
SupportedPer-range effects such as bloom, shake, explode and jitter
Not listed
Stickers
SupportedPlace image stickers on any bubble with position, scale and rotation; sticker events inbound
Not listed
Formatted text
SupportedMarkdown rendered as native bold, italic, underline and strikethrough
Not listedOnly a bold subject line above the body is documented.
Attachments
SupportedFiles up to 100 MiB by default, including Live Photos
SupportedUp to 10 per message, by public URL or presigned upload.
Live Photos
SupportedHEIC still plus MOV companion uploaded as one Live Photo
Not listed
Rich link previews
Supportedrichlink() asks Messages to render its own preview
SupportedFeatures page says URLs expand with title, image and description.
Voice messages
Supported
SupportedisVoiceNote sends one audio file as a native voice memo.
Contact cards
SupportedvCard or structured contacts, plus the bot's own native contact card
SupportedFeatures page lists contact cards; no vCard field is documented in the API.
Polls
SupportedCreate, vote, add options and receive poll events; all managed plans
Not listed
Chat backgrounds
Supported
Not listed
Location sharing
SupportedFind My requests and live location; Business plan
Not listedThe homepage shows a location pin in a send example; the API docs do not cover it.
iMessage apps
SupportedCustom and live app cards; iMessage mini apps on the Business plan
Not listed
Live app cards
SupportedEdit an app card in place and render live UI without a new bubble
Not listed
Sender name and photo
SupportedShares the agent's name and photo automatically; Business plan
Not listed
FaceTime calls
Not listed
SupportedOutbound FaceTime audio and video to Apple users. Inbound auto-answer is production tier only.
Delivery status
SupportedSent, delivered, read and send-error fields per message
Supportedsent, delivered, read and failed events, plus per-message callback URLs.
iMessage availability check
SupportedCheck if a number or email can get iMessage, SMS or RCS before sending
SupportedUp to 100 numbers per call; results are cached and read back.
Focus and Notify Anyway
SupportedCheck if a recipient has Focus on, then trigger Notify Anyway
Not listed
Numbers and delivery
Managed lines
SupportedSpectrum Cloud runs the Mac fleet; no Mac needed
SupportedEach line runs in an isolated macOS VM that Blue Replies provisions.
Dedicated numbers
Supported$250 per line per month on Business
SupportedProduction accounts get a dedicated line.
Shared numbers
SupportedFree and Pro route each user through a managed shared pool
SupportedSandbox uses a shared line, limited to your phone and 5 verified contacts.
Bring your own number
SupportedYour own Apple ID when self-hosting on a Mac, and your own number for WhatsApp Business
Not listed
Line pooling
SupportedBusiness: auto-scale adds lines and a routing endpoint balances users
SupportedArea-code, round-robin, least-loaded, random or sticky routing across lines.
SMS fallback
SupportedOn every plan per pricing; carrier rules apply to fallback traffic
SupportedallowSmsFallback retries over native SMS; needs SMS fallback enabled on the account.
RCS fallback
Supported
Not listedThe pricing page mentions RCS; the API docs do not.
Outbound-first messaging
SupportedBusiness plan, up to 50 new contacts per line per day
SupportedNew outbound conversations ramp from 2 to 50 a day per line.
Calls on the iMessage number
SupportedPlace and receive SIP calls from the line people already text
SupportedFaceTime calls go out from your lines; the callback number defaults to the calling line.
Other channels
SMS
BetaStandalone SMS and MMS numbers with 10DLC in the 2.0 beta; SMS fallback on iMessage lines today
PartialNative SMS only as fallback when an iMessage send fails.
RCS
PartialSent on the iMessage line when the recipient cannot get iMessage
Not listedThe pricing page mentions RCS; the API docs do not.
WhatsApp
SupportedWhatsApp Business, one-to-one, on the Business plan
Not supportedNot offered
Telegram
Supported
Not supported
Slack
Supported@spectrum-ts/slack provider on npm and GitHub
Not supportedNot offered as a channel; Slack appears only in an integrations list.
Email
BetaYour own domain with DKIM, SPF and inbound MX in the 2.0 beta
Not supportedNot offered
Phone calls
SupportedSIP calls on iMessage lines; the 2.0 beta adds calls on SMS numbers
Not listedThe pricing page lists Voice; the docs cover FaceTime calls only.
Apple Messages for Business
BetaListed as available in the 2.0 beta
Not listed
Unified channel API
SupportedOne Spectrum SDK across channels, and one REST model in the 2.0 beta
SupportediMessage and SMS fallback go through the same messages endpoint.
Developer tools
REST API
SupportedREST API for projects and lines; sending over REST in the 2.0 beta
Supported
TypeScript SDK
Supportedspectrum-ts, plus low-level iMessage and WhatsApp SDKs
Not listedDocs name npm package blueapi, but that npm name belongs to an unrelated 2018 package.
Python SDK
Betaphotonhq-api on PyPI, for the 2.0 beta API
Not supportedSDK page says no official Python SDK exists yet; a Jan 2026 changelog entry mentions one.
Other SDKs
SupportedGo client for Advanced iMessage; Rust and Go clients for the 2.0 API
Not supportedSDK page says no official Ruby, Go, PHP or Elixir SDK exists yet.
CLI
Supported@photon-ai/cli manages projects, lines, users and billing
Not listed
Webhooks
Supported
Supported29 event types across messages, calls, lines, groups and workflows.
Signed webhooks
SupportedHMAC-SHA256, plus Standard Webhooks signatures
SupportedHMAC-SHA256 in x-bluereplies-signature.
MCP server
SupportedHosted MCP server, plus an MCP server for the docs
Not listedDocs mention an MCP server with a search_docs tool, but no endpoint is documented.
Open source
SupportedMIT: spectrum-ts, imessage-kit and most SDKs
Not listed
Self-hosting
SupportedRun the open-source core on your own Mac and number, no Spectrum Cloud
Not listed
Local testing
SupportedTerminal chat UI provider, no phone or number needed
Not listedThe sandbox sends real iMessages to your own activated phone.
Custom channel providers
SupporteddefinePlatform plugs any interface into the same Spectrum API
Not listed
Event replay
SupportedCatch up on events after a disconnect from a durable sequence
SupportedRetries up to 24 hours, then replay any delivery from the dashboard or by API.
OpenTelemetry
SupportedOpt-in messaging traces in spectrum-ts, and traces in the 2.0 beta dashboard
Not listed
No-code integrations
Supportedn8n community nodes and a Dify plugin
SupportedSite says customers connect through Zapier or GoHighLevel; no setup docs found.
CRM integrations
Not listed
SupportedSite lists HubSpot and Salesforce; no setup docs found.
Built for AI agents
Agent framework
SupportedSpectrum is a multi-channel agent framework with streaming replies
Not listedThe Enterprise plan lists in-house workflow builders and AI agents; not documented.
Agent framework integrations
SupportedVercel Chat SDK, Mastra, LangChain, Convex and others
Not listed
Streaming replies
SupportedAI output streams into one iMessage bubble, edited in place
Not listed
Agent group chats
BetaAgents find other agents and add them to a group chat (2.0 beta)
Not listed
Human handoff
BetaA person can reply in a conversation from the 2.0 beta Inbox
Not listed
Audit logs
BetaAPI logs and traces in the 2.0 beta dashboard
Not listedThe public OpenAPI spec lists a portal audit-log endpoint, but it is not documented.
Message history API
SupportedList and get messages per chat
SupportedList conversations and messages, with filters and full-text search.
Plans and compliance
Free plan
SupportedUp to 10 users on shared lines
SupportedSandbox is free with no expiry: your own phone plus up to 5 verified contacts.
Public pricing
Supported
Not supportedPricing FAQ says production prices are quoted per customer.
No per-message fees
SupportedNo per-message fees for iMessage, WhatsApp or Telegram; SMS, voice and email are metered in the 2.0 beta
Not supportedPricing page says production typically costs under $0.01 per delivered message.
Uptime SLA
SupportedContractual SLA on the Enterprise plan
Partial99.9% uptime SLA, listed on the Enterprise plan.
Isolated infrastructure
SupportedEach line runs in an isolated, dedicated environment
SupportedEach line runs in an isolated macOS VM.
SOC 2 Type II
SupportedStated on photon.codes
Not listedTrust page cites SOC 2 Type II hosting providers, not a report of its own.
GDPR
SupportedPrivacy policy covers GDPR rights and SCC transfers
Not listedAbout page says GDPR-ready; no DPA or GDPR page found.

Checked on each provider's own site and docs on 2026-10-25. “Not listed” means the provider does not mention it.

Pricing

Photon

Free plan, Pro at $25/month, Business at $250 per dedicated line per month, and custom Enterprise; the 2.0 beta adds metered SMS, voice and email.

Pricing model: plan tiers plus flat fee per dedicated line

Source

Blue Replies

The Sandbox is free with no expiry for sending to your own phone and up to 5 verified contacts; production is quote-based and typically under $0.01 per delivered message.

Pricing model: per delivered message, by quote

Source

Which should you choose?

Choose Photon if you need mentions, animated text effects, stickers and formatted text.

Choose Blue Replies if you need FaceTime calls and CRM integrations.

Frequently asked questions